FORM REFEREE'S REPORT

 

REFEREE - FORM FOR Report ON THE MANUSCRIPT


 

Please CRITICALLY REVIEW THE PAPER AND MUST GIVE COMMENTS ON EACH TOPIC IN ADDITION YOU MAY ALSO mark with a SERIAL NUMBER if applicable

 


© To reproduce copyright material

Author should not use any copyright material (figure/tables etc.) In the paper. However he/she may refer to that in the form of text in the paper

 


Please check author must avoid use of political tone and comments on any region, race/ethnic group, religion, class, caste etc. In the paper

 


Ο          Topic suitable

(1. Yes, 2. Marginal, 3. Not at all)

Comments:

 


Ο          Information

(1. Original, 2. Confirmatory, 3. Trivial/nonsense)

Comments:

 


Ο          Academic value

(1. Excellent, 2. Sound/partly sound, 3. Poor/doubtful)

Comments:

 


Ο          Title

(1. Clear/adequate, 2. Needs modification, 3. Inappropriate)

Comments:

 


Ο          RUNNING HEAD:

(1. Clear/adequate, 2. Needs modification, 3. Inappropriate)

Comments:

 


Ο          KEYWORDS:

(1. Clear/adequate, 2. Needs modification, 3. I Inadequate)

Comments:

 


Ο          Abstract

(1. Clear/adequate, 2. Minor revisions, 3. Inadequate/unclear)

Comments:

 


Ο          INTRODUCTION

(1. importance of studying of topic, 2. Convincing rationale of study, 3. Review of Literature on topic)

Comments:

 


Ο          OBJECTIVES

(1. importance of studying of topic, 2. Convincing rationale of study, 33. Inappropriate/erroneous)

Comments:

 


Ο          Data/MATERIAL

(1. Appropriate/Sufficiently large, 2. Appropriate but too limited, 3.Inappropriate)

Comments:

 


Ο          Methods

(1. Appropriate for aims, 2. Too simple, 3. Inappropriate/erroneous)

Comments:

 


Ο          RESULTS

(1. Correct 2. Mainly correct 3. Wrong preliminary/speculative)

Comments:

 


Ο          Discussion

(1. Correct/warranted by results, 2. Mainly correct 3. Wrong preliminary/speculative)

Comments:

 


O          CONCLUSION

(1. Correct/warranted by Discussion 2. Mainly correct 3. Wrong preliminary/speculative)

Comments:

 


O          RECOMMENDATIONS

(1. Correct/warranted by Discussion 2. Mainly correct 3. Wrong preliminary/speculative)

Comments:

 


Ο          HEADINGS, SUBHEADINGS AND SUB-SUBHEADINGS

(1. Clear/adequate, 2. Needs modification, 3. Inappropriate)

Comments:

 


Ο          abbreviations

(1. Clear/adequate, 2. Needs modification, 3. Inappropriate)

Comments:

 


Ο          Statistical Symbols

(1. Clear/adequate, 2. Needs modification, 3. Inappropriate)

Comments:

 


Ο          FOOTNOTES/ENDNOTES

(1. Clear, 2. Needs modification, 3. Inappropriate)

Comments:

 


Ο          References

(1. Complete/adequate, 2. Sufficient, 3. Insufficient/partly irrelevant)

Comments:

 


Ο          Figures-PHOTOGRAPH/GRAPH/MAP/CHART

(1. Appropriate/excellent quality, 2. Adequate, 3. Poor quality/messy)

Comments:

 


Ο          Tables

(1. Appropriate/clearly presented, 2. Adequate, 3. Messy/inadequate number)

Comments:

 


Ο          Language

(1. Correct grammar and style, 2. Minor corrections needed 3. Poor, needs major revision)

Comments:

 


Ο          conclusion and recommendation to the Editors

 


Ο          Status of the paper

Ο          PAPER MAY BE -

Ο          Accepted

Ο          Acceptable After Minor Revision

Ο          Acceptable After Moderate Revision. No need to referee again

Ο          Acceptable After Substantial Revision. Needs to be re-referred

Ο          Not Acceptable in the Present Form

Ο          Other

Ο          Finally Accepted / Not Acceptable in the Present Form

 


Address for all correspondence:

Mona Mukhija

Administrative Editor

B-2 (Ground Floor), South City II,

Gurgaon 122 018, Haryana, India

Telephone:  091-0124-4360430

E-mail: editor@krepublishers.co.in,

Website: http://www.krepublishers.com